2.12.2016

Dem Bones: Revisited

   Life is full of mistakes, missed opportunities, false hopes and broken dreams. What does that mean for us? I threw out the bones!
   I know, with all my talk on stretching ingredients, I should've known better. As it turns out, those bones are on their way to a landfill somewhere, destined to eventually re-enter the ecological cycles that saw their creation. But, it leaves me to wonder what a second stock might have looked and tasted like in comparison to the prototype.
   Remouillage is the term for "re-wetting" bones for this second stock. Its primary purpose serves efficiencyextending the use of those bones for flavor and body. Veal bones tend to be the routine, which sources suggest is due to veal's higher market price. And the reason money actually matters here is that the product of a remouillage (called the same) is traditionally nothing special. You wouldn't ordinarily use a second stock the same way as a fresh one. In fact, it's often simply added to the first and reduced (i.e., boiled down).
   Other practical uses for a remouillage include replacing water in a recipe, such as for a soup that would use your first stock or for a risotto; reducing it to form a glaze for meats; etc.

A Good Source

   Going back to stock, the best of the best will utilize joints more than straight sections of bone. Knuckles, neck, and similar areas which happen to have less meat would be full of tendons, ligaments, and cartilage; chicken feet fall especially within this category. Considered inedible and unpleasant to the average palate, these parts are perfect for making stock; and after seeing what's really left from boiling bones, you'll know why.

January 23, 2016 - Beef Stock Scraps

   To see the bone beforehand, it's hard to imagine just how little of it was actually bone. I can't discern weight very well, but for the size of that raw bone, 1½ pounds felt very heavy. In reality, it was merely dense. That inner collagen-matrix (or scaffold, as some call it)—what we simply refer to as the marrow—ultimately melted down and became the broth. And that's exactly what you're looking for when you slowcook a bone for hours.
   The leftover bone itself (pictured) obviously could have withstood a lot more pressure. But the question is, would it have been worth it? to simmer that bone until there'd be nothing solid left to discard? Before you answer that, you have to be certain of one thing: where did your bones come from?

The Element of Surprise

   Apparently, there's a lot of controversy over the risks of consuming a bone broth; and we're not talking about swallowing bone fragments. A healthy bone consists of calcium and phosphorous, dense collagen, and numerous micronutrients. However, bones are also a repository for toxic elements such as lead (Pb). The health-scare comes from the belief that this lead will seep into the broth alongside the beneficial elements. So then, sourcing your bones to healthier animals, those which are less likely to have consumed lead in the first place, is your best option for combatting this claim.
   I say "claim" because a January-2013 study took a lot of heat for its well-meaning public alert regarding lead exposure in bone broth. A scathing, comprehensive review of it can be seen here. While lead, when it is present, does effectively contaminate the stock, there was much left unsaid about the source of the researchers' samples (chicken parts as well as the water used). But to return to the thought at hand, how and where an animal is raised has much to do with the nutrition consuming it will pass on.
   Lead is one of those elements that plagues our environment and never goes away; it is labeled "non-essential and toxic." A by-product of mining, some countries are more affected by it than others. It can be present in soils to varying degrees (including absence), but it is also present in the atmosphere. Soil-lead tends to remain sequestered within a plant's roots (read here), while atmospheric dust accounts for the majority of lead present in a plant's shoots (reference here) or in the plant as a whole (read here). The point of all this is to say, if lead is in the plants, it is in the food chain; and whether we're consuming the animals that feed on leaded plants, or other plants fertilized with those animals' manure, lead is likely in our diet as well.
   As with any toxin, however, there is a limit. (Indeed, some naturally occurring poisonous compounds, if consumed, will only result in sickness, not death.) By natural order, most of the lead which enters the body moves into the animal's bones, humans included. This keeps it far from the systems which would ultimately end up most affected by it. If lead concentrations grow too great, the effects start to poison various metabolic processes throughout the body. So the operative question is, how does the body remove lead from its stores?
   This author relates it to the advantage of the mineral selenium on the detriment of mercury (both from the consumption of fish). Where mercury aims to replace selenium and destroy those puzzle-piece enzymes in the process, a greater quantity of selenium will inhibit this effect. Lead has a similar relationship with calcium and iron, but by extension, calcium and iron guard against the bodily absorption of lead. Additionally, vitamins such as D, C and B1 help to pass lead into the urine to be removed entirely from the body.
   Expounding upon a previous point and bringing us back to the bone, homemade stock is not a huge source of calcium (read here). This is because, while the majority of a bone is in fact comprised of calcium and phosphorous, those elements are each part of an insoluble compound (reference here). Suffice it to say, boiling water will not leach calcium from a bone. This is where strong acids such as undiluted vinegar or hydrochloric acid come into play. Not only does this mean eating a bone can be beneficial (consider fish bones), but it makes me really want to utilize a vinegar bath for the start of a remouillage.

Take a Collagen Course

   Collagen is the real reason for the bone-broth hype. There is at least a score of types of collagen, differentiated by their structure, as dictated by the levels of the amino acids within them. These types are enumerated after Roman fashion, and the five most common are explained in this video. Of those, types I and III are the most abundant. Type I is found within the skin, bones, tendons, etc.; type III is common to blood vessels and muscles, as well as alongside type I. Type II is present in cartilage, and it also makes up the entirety of the eye's vitreous. Type IV is found in the eye's lens, and is a part of the body's filtration system. Type V is a major component of the placenta, and it also found in the space between cells.

The By-Products' Juices Produce These Uses

   If you've skipped straight to this section, I don't blame you. What follows is really the focus to this post: you've made the broth, you've done the easy part; now what? Well, every bit of your previous recipe has its place. Assuming your stock has been freshly strained at this moment, I'd first like to address the leftovers.
   Especially if you used meat in your stock, these strained items (sans bones, bay leaves, etc.) have a revival story to tell. That bowlful of slowcooked goodness may look melt-in-your-mouth scrumptious, but the science of making stock reminds us that there is little to no flavor left in those scraps. However, the fact that they haven't completely dissolved tells us that there is still nutrition to them.
   A couple of uses include homemade dog food or reconstituting them into a stew. Now, I'm no vet, and I've actually never owned a dog, but I've always been intrigued by the families who've prepped meals for their dogs. And let's face it: this looks the part. Right alongside that idea, putting them in a stew just sounds redundant. I mean, you just removed them from the liquid. If you're going to put them back in and add salt and potatoes, what have you really accomplished? But, hey, the options get better from here.
   I thought about it a moment and decided to make shepherd's pie (recipe to follow). Those casseroles of my childhood utilized ground beef, peas and carrots. These leftovers looked even more appetizing, so why not try it? To balance out their lack of flavor, you could either use a marinade on them or really dress up their blanket of mashed potatoes.
   Similarly, online sources suggest baking the leftovers into a gravy-laden pot pie.

mmm, pudding

   No, that's not a pot pie. Neither is it pudding, but it really looked like it, especially considering Jes had recently made matcha-white-chocolate pudding.
   That, my friends, is pure beef fat. Lard. If you'll recall, I said I won't cook with the store-bought, manufactured variety. (It's too much to worry about sources, techniques, age, nutrition; not to mention, that's one thing I wouldn't want to buy in bulk.) Most people advocate throwing this out. I mean, it has separated itself, and refrigeration's made it solid and therefore easy-to-remove.

pie crust

   I endorse removing, but also reserving. After attacking the ice-sheet with a blunt knife and a spatula, it portions itself nicely. Just put them in the freezer and take out a piece as needed. You can use it in place of butter in most recipes (homemade biscuits, but not homemade biscotti; this is beef-flavored, after all). Commenters here suggest warming it and basting pre-cooked meat to effectively turn a conventional oven into a microwave oven, or melting it over dog food as a treat that results in a healthier coat. Jes and I might try rubbing it on a roast or a London broil. Additionally, because rendered fat has a decent smoke point and a ton of flavor, it can also be used for the base of a roux.
   Other ideas, including for oil sourced from other animals, can be read here.

apple sauce

   Finally comes the gelatinous gem itself: stock. How should you use it, beside exploiting its unsettling texture in a video? Well, following the thought of roux, why not make it the base of your gumbo? You know I'm tempted to try that—and, of course, document it. Similarly, as with any stock, once you salt it, you've got a broth and you're well on your way to making soup. These are the kind of meals what make winter bearable, am I right?
   If you really reduce this down, you'll end up with a gravy that makes you rethink the canned stuff. I'm not a fan of that gravy, but I love meat au jus; for me, it's a matter of redefining what gravy should be, and this is definitely the way to do that.
   As if there weren't enough recipe variants for soups, stews, and gumbos to keep you busy, maybe you'll feel up to the task of creating an aspic. Too often is this traditional garnish turned into a culinary tragedy, as savory jello molds come to mind. But an aspic should work as a cold spread, even a condiment, for the meat it's derived from. Fish tends to be a popular one. Of course, if you're really interested in the nightmarish version, you might at least be better off using powdered gelatin to accomplish your deeds.

2.01.2016

Dem Bones

   Bones are those wonderful by-products which I've never had trouble accepting. Jes, on the other hand— it is really curious how opposite we were when it came to food.

   Thirteen seasons ago, when Jes and I first met, she did not eat anything with bones in it. When we made it our routine to visit Pizza Hut every Wednesday for 50¢ wings, she always got the bone-out variety. Whenever my mom invited us over for chicken breasts and thighs and legs, she made a filet or two for Jes. And I can't tell you how many times I'd decided not to order BBQ ribs because Jes would be watching me eat them. Don't worry; I get the same effect when I have to see people bite something frozen.
   I've at least made an art of eating meat off the bone. Ever since my college years, where countless chicken wings were devoured, I'd learned to utilize a fork to keep my fingers from getting messy. It's just one of those habits that stuck, though it takes more than a few balancing acts to glean bones spotless, especially ribs. Once in a while, I will dirty a knife, if only to display some etiquette.
   It may have taken a meal of chicken cacciatore to bring Jes around, with meat that literally fell off the bone and left her to simply trim off the cartilage. She'll take a knife to a chicken breast now and then, or a bone-in steak, but she'll always opt for a filet if and when she can.

A Bone to Pick with You

   As for my world, bones were more than simply the inedible structure within a flavor-packed, moist piece of dark meat (my preference), or the T of a tender chop, or the eye of a succulent hunk of ham. That is, it wasn't just the end of a meal. No; within my family, the bone's status was exalted as part of the meal, and for my brother and I at least, it was a delicacy to be included in it.
   I'm talking about yebret, giddo's dish of unmatched fame which can only as yet be recreated by others in the family. Lemon-soaked, garlic-smothered, lamb-and-rice-stuffed grape leaves served steaming hot into an open pita, or as is. But when giddo was still with us, there were always bones in the pot. Remnants, yes, from a tall order of a lamb leg, from which he'd get meat for kebabs and burgers alike—the bones were cut and cleaned, boiled and prepped, and then cooked once more alongside those soggy green cigars.

August 26, 2007 - Giddo's Yebret and Bones

   Don't knock it 'til you've tried it.
   Each bone held a scrap or two of tough meat, which soaking in lemon juice not only infused it with such vibrant flavor, but also wore into and tenderized it. To get a chunk of lemony muscle off a bone was my favorite part of the meal, but you'd be surprised how few bones actually had any sizable piece of meat on them. So what, then, was the point of adding them? The marrow.
   My brother loved it. My dad loved it. Giddo loved it. I...took a few years to get into it. It did, after all, have the same flavor as the meat; it's just that texture that gets to you. I could explain it for you, but honestly, it snot very appetizing.

April 7, 2013 - Jerm's Ossobuco

   Nowadays, though it's been a while since we've had lamb bones with our yebret, my brother occasionally cooks bones for us, whether they be loaded with meat as the central part of an Italian stew, or sections of beef bone prepared solely for consuming their marrow. I won't try to sell the marrow-eating anymore—it's just one of those things. But you'll be glad to know of one other way to ingest that goodness.

The Bone Broth

   Previously, I'd mentioned the difference between stock and broth (rich vs. mild, concentrated vs. thin, unsalted vs. salted). Well, some people simply define "stock" as bone broth. I'll grant them that. Stock, for the most part, utilizes skeletal pieces for imparting flavor, nutrients and texture. I generalized "skeletal" to include shellfish. Indeed, some people say "vegetable stock" is a misnomer—that, unless it made use of bones, it is really only broth. Call it what you want, as long as we're talking about the same thing.
   Jes and I went shopping one day and bought a prepackaged section of beef bone. This thing was obviously meant for one purpose, and I wanted to give it that. We got home, I stuck it in the freezer, and we waited for the motivation to actually do something with it. Well, motivation came in the form of 4 of my brother's roasted beef bones, each significantly smaller than the one we purchased. The leftovers were gifted and frozen (you see a pattern) until a Saturday's free time came along.

January 23, 2016 - Beef Stock

   Plenty of online literature suggests roasting bones prior to making stock with them, the first of them explaining it away as imparting a stronger flavor. Like roasting carrots before adding them to a stew, I can attest to that pleasant change of pace. However, the reason I didn't do the same to our 1½-lb beef marrow bone was firstly due to time-constraints, and secondly because I wondered if a fresh bone would add its own unique flavor. This wasn't exactly the proper way of testing that theory, but I really didn't care. This is a kitchen, not a laboratory. However, you will find that using an uncooked bone does add something "constructive" to the stock.

January 23, 2016 - Beef Stock

   This may be the opportune moment to mention the method behind a proper bone stock: the longer you cook it, the better it becomes. The minimum cook-time for simmering bones is 8 hours; the maximum is undisclosed. Many sources suggested 24 hours optimally, and that is what I went with. Ultimately, it depends upon the type of bones you are cooking. Fish bones, for example, wouldn't require as much time as chicken bones, and neither could compete with a mammal's femur.
   The reason behind cooking bones for such a long time is to extract the most nutrients from them. Bones are a matrix of protein, calcium, magnesium, etc.; as harder surfaces break down, pockets open up and their contents melt away. If boiled over a long enough period of time, bones will become porous or even begin to dissolve completely into their stock.
   Bones, cartilage, and skin are the greatest sources of collagen in the body. (Suddenly, the broth brand College Inn begins to make sense.) Collagen, a fibrous protein, boasts numerous health benefits, though it is important to understand that it collapses under high heat. Gelatin is the end-product of boiled collagen; it is so named because of its "freezing" (Latin) effect on liquids under refrigerated temperatures. Collagen, on the other hand, keeps its structure well into the range of body temperature. Can you imagine if it didn't?
   Broken-down collagen is nutritionally just as goodnot to mention more pleasant to consume—as naturally occurring collagen. As with anything our bodies digest, the resulting macro- and micronutrients are the literal building blocks of life. Our bodies make collagen if they have the ingredients at their disposal.

   Getting back to particulars, knowing how long you're going to be applying heat is half the battle. Calculating how much you're going to be making is the other half. At this point, I had two options to consider: either I'd slowcook the stock in our 2-quart crockpot, or I'd leave it in a 5-quart pot on our electric stovetop and hope it never boiled over. I honestly wanted to choose the slowcooker, but the raw bone alone would have taken up half the space. So, when in doubt, go the extra mile.

January 23, 2016 - Beef Stock

   The final bit of flavor came from trimmings we had saved in our freezer. These included beef and fat as well as garlic leftover from some meal or such. After neatly arranging these six items in the pot, there was one crucial addition that almost every source suggests: vinegar. Especially in the case of our raw bone, the acid of vinegar helps break down chemical bonds. This results in, above all, an accelerated detachment of meat, marrow, and effectively calcium from the bone. I presume a bath or marinade would have done as proper a job (something to try next time), but instead I poured ½ cup raspberry red-wine vinegar over the bones. I would say keep red-wine to red-meat and white-wine to white-meat, out of preference; the raspberry just happens to be the only kind we have at the moment.
   As for the amount of vinegar to use, it varies based on the type of bone and the amount of water. Some people attest to having a strong vinegar "odor" while cooking, and use less based upon that result. By comparison, my vinegar-to-water ratio was higher than suggested, and the overwhelming aroma was not vinegar. More on that later.
   I can't measure the water accurately, because when making any broth you should go by the amount of solids and the dimensions of the pot. That said, as you should have expected, I added filtered water to cover. Finally, for this first stage, I added 2 bay leaves, 1½ teaspoons whole peppercorns, and 1 Tablespoon dried parsley (for lack of fresh). Then you bring this to a boil and turn it down to a simmer, which I left on the stove for ~13 hours. This point was the most stressful, honestly, because I had started all of this at midnight and proceeded to sleep through at least the first half of this cook-time.

January 23, 2016 - Beef Stock

   Bubbles naturally rise to the surface when boiling water; however, when cooking meat, vegetables, or even pasta, there is more to those bubbles than air. The uppermost layer of broth becomes a film of "impurities"—traditionally containing more unhealthy components (which I won't scare you with) than they do nowadays. In our case, denatured (broken-down) proteins are what form this sudsy surface. Recalling that collagen is one such protein, leaving this foam where it is will ensure that it remains a part of the cooled end-product. Because it attributes a cloudy look to broth, however, some people skim this off (while it is easiest to do so, i.e., boiling).
   Other people—and this goes back to a previous step—cook their bones once over to reduce the amount of available protein before bathing them for stock. For the boost of flavor and added clarity, one is trading nutrition and texture, because of the significant lack of gelatin in the end. "They" say that you know you've made stock right if you achieve that jelling texture, but "they" must not like roasting their bones.
   Since I utilized both raw and roasted, I believe I got the best of both worlds. But it's the roasted bones that really made cooking this worthwhile. Either that, or we were simply driven insane, because they were all we smelled throughout our apartment for literally every minute of that Saturday. Beneath that scent was the garlic; the vinegar never even crossed our nostrils.

January 23, 2016 - Beef Stock

   Vegetables give even more nutrition to stock, and actually, some of them can contribute more calcium than the bones would (see here). They also add vibrancy to the flavor, as do fresh herbs. But they obviously don't require as much heat as the bones do, which is why they're added nearer to the end of the bath. At 13½ hours in, I added frozen vegetable scraps (from carrots, celery and onions), about an equivalent amount as the frozen beef trimmings. Additional water as needed kept these mostly submerged. The problem with vegetables is that they tend to float.
   After simmering for another 6½ hours, fresher vegetables went in: 1 celery stalk, 1 carrot and the skins of 1 onion. Then I kicked up the heat very slightly (still considered low) for the final 4 hours.

   As midnight rolled around once again, the heat went off and I was prepping a strainer-cheesecloth combination over a 2½-quart glass bowl. If possible, I would advise using two sets of hands for this. I managed without, but only barely. Did you know clear tape loses its adhesion under extreme heat?
   I'm not particular about broth clarity, and after the hassle of straining once I definitely wouldn't have chosen to run it through a second time. Besides, of all the things our kitchen has, large containers are a rarity. We ended up with nearly 2 quarts of liquid, as measured after due refrigeration and transferrance to a more freezer-friendly vessel.

January 23, 2016 - Beef Stock

   It's important to let this cool properly before placing in the refrigerator. That oil slick is still well above 100 degrees. I loosely covered this bowl for the night while it sat on the counter (did I mention our kitchen is more sterile than most?), then put it in the fridge once morning came.
   For the aftermath and more useful tips, jump to the end of my next post.

Other sources:
http://paleoleap.com/eat-this-bone-broth/
http://whole9life.com/2013/12/whole9-bone-broth-faq/